Posted 16 January 2013 - 11:10 AM
Unfortunately there is no rule of thumb and as you suspect it depends on what look you like, or what look you grow to like after experimenting. Every method has pros and cons.
You can apply underglaze to unfired work but you lose some of the ability to correct mistakes ..e.g. you can just wash the underglaze off of bisque ware.
You can fire between underglaze applications to seal the work in place so the next step doesn't ruin it ... but, the wrong glaze could still make it bleed or run. Some underglaze colors are more prone to bleeding on the edges.
You can use wax resist or latex resist to protect your carved designs from glaze, but the wrong glaze could still run there during firing.
Every single way of doing it is favored by someone and disliked by someone else. So, I would strongly recommend you make a bunch of test tiles in an L shape and carve some designs on the long side ... then do some tests until you come up with a look you like. That will be your 'right' answer.
Chris Campbell
Contemporary Fine Colored Porcelain
www.ccpottery.com
"My Artwork would not exist without a thriving global pottery community.
In the isolation of a studio, an artist can begin to feel like an island, but in truth
we are all part of archipelagoes; chains of islands loosely connected by a stream
of information that enhances our Artwork.”